Butt ugly Adsense ads make more money


If I were you, I would read this whole post, even if some bits in the beginning don’t interest you. You will see why as you reach the end.

Here is a little story. I was trying to promote a little website I had that I created to sell a product.

(You know, one of those sites where you have a long salesletter and a big buy button that you can click to order an e-book or whatever? Yeah, that one. I used to hate them too, till I started creating them and making money from them. ;-) For example, this website I mention consists of exactly three pages and makes about $1500-$2000 per month for me in profits. Anyway, on with the story…)

So there I was, trying to use Adwords to promote the site.

(Yes, yes, I know I said Adsense in the title of the post. Bear with me, my friend!)

Anyway. So I was trying to use Adwords to promote the site. I was already seeing great results in the search network, and wanted to try advertising in the content network as well.

As you may know, the “content network” consists of the actual web sites that display all these ads that we call Adsense ads. From the advertisers point of view, it’s the Adwords ads displaying on the “content network,” and from our point of view, it’s Adsense ads.

Anyway, this is what I found:

  • Unless you are willing to pay high click costs, your ads will get displayed in lower positions where no one will see them
  • Unless anyone sees them, you won’t any clicks
  • If you want clicks, you need to either raise your bids, or experiment with image ads (which I did) because they have far less competition than text ads
  • Image ads that look like they are designed by a graphic designer tend to get very poor results in terms of clicks. On the other hand, image ads that look like “text” perform much better
  • A few words on a big sized image ad work the best
  • Big sized image ads with a few words on them and a horrible color combination work the “bestest”

So what does this mean for us SBIers?

What the above means is that we have just stumbled upon a cool way to make more money from the Adsense ads that get displayed on our sites. Now, read carefully here, and try to follow the logic. This is important.

  • The image ads I mentioned above worked well because they drew attention
  • They drew attention because they looked ugly and out of place in the website
  • Looking at this from our (webmasters) point of view, the ads that draw attention will get more clicks and hence make more money for us
  • But image ads typically pay a lot less than text ads, which have higher competition
  • So if we customize our (text) Adsense ads to make them look ugly, we get the best of both worlds – ads that draw attention and ads that pay more

Just trying to make sure you didn’t miss that last one: If we customize our (text) Adsense ads to make them look ugly, we get the best of both worlds – ads that draw attention and ads that pay more.

I am sure you already know how to customize the look of your Adsense ads, so I won’t go into that here.

A word of caution

It’s important to be careful here. You don’t want to create ads SO ugly that they make you lose your credibility with your visitors. For example, don’t have ads that hurt the eyes, or make your site look like a kaleidoscope.

It’s a fine line you need to walk. In my opinion, always err on the side of making more money. You are monetizing, after all. You can always change it back to a little less ugly if it doesn’t work for you.

And don’t forget to do some testing of your own first. Just because it looks like a good idea, it doesn’t mean you will necessarily have success with it. Always test an idea first, before rolling it out full scale.

So what do you think of this approach? Good? Bad? Ugly? I would love to hear your thoughts in the comments below. And if you have similar (or different) experiences of your own, please share.

Like this post? Why not share it with others too:
  • Digg
  • Sphinn
  • del.icio.us
  • Facebook
  • Google Bookmarks
  • FriendFeed
  • Live
  • Reddit
  • StumbleUpon
  • Twitter

Related posts:

  1. Examples of ugly Adsense ads

  1. #1 by MaryAnn The Business Plan Gal at May 26th, 2009

    Rohit, sadly I think you’ve got a minor brainstorm. “Sadly” because I wish websites could look pretty. And in my gut I know you are right.

    I remember when I first started analyzing ads. The sites that had slews of ads, and were not so neatly displayed, seemed to be the sites that did well.

    So the whole equation may be sloppy + ugly = profitable.

    So sad. So sad.

    But thanks for sharing. I don’t feel quite so alone in my gut feeling.

  2. #2 by Cliff Calderwood at May 26th, 2009

    You have my attention but I’m having difficulty visualizing what you’re talking about can you provide an example?

    Cliff

  3. #3 by gingertakamiya at May 26th, 2009

    I love the thought line. Now all I have to do is decipher it! :) I have not started to use Adsense on my site yet. Going to do that this summer. I’m still learning to monetize at this time so boy to I have a long way to go to even make my first penny!

    Thanks for the advice though, I’ll tuck it away for later this summer!

  4. #4 by Dawn at May 26th, 2009

    I would certainly not be surprised if your theory is spot on. I have noticed much better CTR since I stopped trying to be discreet with my Adsense and just slapped a large, centered ad straight under the headline.

    Good idea and I shall do some experimenting.

    Thanks.

  5. #5 by Jane at May 26th, 2009

    Can you give a website address to show an example of some of these ‘ugly’ ads. I’d sure like to make some money from adsense, or anything for that matter. I am about to start monetizing a second site with adsense so need all the hlep I can get.

    By the way, this site is a great idea.

    Thanks
    Jane

  6. #6 by Julia Rymut at May 26th, 2009

    Hi Rohit,

    Thanks for the great tips. I haven’t really started experimenting with my adsense design but when I get to it, I’ll keep this in mind. I must admit, though, aesthetically your advice makes me cringe! :) But we’ll see how I feel if my check goes up!

    Julia

  7. #7 by Miriam at May 26th, 2009

    Hi Rohit,
    OK, I’m giving it a try, not sure how much “ugliness” this will take… will let you know how it goes.

    Miriam

  8. #8 by Dr Ellen at May 27th, 2009

    Hi Rohit!
    Thanks for sharing your thoughts and tips. As a few posters before me alreaady queried, can you give an example so we can see the “fine” line?

    Ellen

  9. #9 by crayden at May 27th, 2009

    Thanks for that, interesting. It sort of takes the lead from general marketing practise.

    The ads that appear on TV where you think they are stupid or a pain such as many washing poweder ads, they are generally the most successfull as people remeber them.

    The ads that are interesting tend to be subconciously are regarded as entertainement so dont enter our memory so easily.

    So its a basic marketing principal realy something that is a PITA will be noticed.

    The difference comes once you have established a brand or a site. Then you have to change to show the image of your site to your visitors.

    So I think it will work but not in every instance.

    entrepreneur-ideas.org

  10. #10 by Leonard at May 27th, 2009

    I can kinda see the logic and how ugly ads draw attention. I am working toward playing with adsense but I will keep this lesson in mind.

  11. #11 by Ronnie Kellner at May 27th, 2009

    this is fabulous information, and I so believe this is true without even testing! I hate testing and so, I haven’t made that much money from my adsense so far, but now I feel motivated to try new things, I was under the impression that they (adsense) have to blend in to the web page – maybe to lull the reader into thinking that is part of the content…. anyway, I am so going to test your theory Rohit. Great Post!and thanks MaryAnn the business plan gal for directing me to Rohit’s post

  12. #12 by Helen at May 27th, 2009

    I’m sure i knew this subconciously but have been trying to ignore it – i’m really not into ugly! But I guess I’ll give it a try. Thanks

  13. #13 by Ilene at May 27th, 2009

    Hmmm, it almost makes sense. I have “colorized” my adsense ads to blend right in…not stand out too much. As a web designer that would “sloppy, poorly put together, amateur”. But wait, if the ones that blend so beautifully aren’t making very much $$ then wouldn’t it seem logical that ones that “stand out”, even if it is because they’re ugly, would create more attention and hence, more profits?
    I’m willing to test it, but would like some examples to get some ideas.

  14. #14 by Rohit Sinha at May 27th, 2009

    Hi all, sorry for the late response, but I have created a new post with a few examples, which you can see here:

    http://www.sbi-mall.com/blog/examples-of-ugly-adsense-ads/

    MaryAnn, thanks for telling people about this little blog of mine. :-)

    Cheers everyone, I am glad you found this idea thought provoking, and now let’s get some testing done to really find out if it works.

  15. #15 by Diane Massad at May 28th, 2009

    Your thoughts and disclosures based on experience are very eye-opening. Just as I am ramping up my launch and structuring my site..the veil of manipulations that are a part of this process, drape the project. Thank though for the honesty.

  16. #16 by MaryAnn The Business Plan Gal at May 31st, 2009

    OK. First round of testing is in. On my site, it is a dud. My CTR chopped in half instantly. My people didn’t like the yellow background, and they didn’t like the grey background, and they didn’t even like green urls in the AdSense ads. The mostly standard formatting with blue underlined urls seems to work best.

    Now, my site visitors are (a) more educated than most, and (b) more female than most. So I draw two conclusions:

    1. Smart, educated women don’t like to be manipulated, or

    2. The regular blue underlined urls are “different” enough on my site to stand out.

    Take your pick. It might be some of both.

  17. #17 by Rohit Sinha at May 31st, 2009

    MaryAnn, knowing what I know after the results/CTRs of my image ads, I would try out quite a few more color combinations till I came across a winner.

  18. #18 by Jonathan Steele at June 3rd, 2009

    Wow, who would have though.

    I remember reading once about how ugly sites outperform beautiful sites. Why should it not also work with advertising too.

    Will be trying this soon.

  19. #19 by Rohit Sinha at June 3rd, 2009

    Great to know you will be trying this out, Jonathan, but do remember to do a few tests first, to find the combination that works best for you. :)

(will not be published)